The shoes are well-constructed with durable rubber soles and high-quality leather uppers, providing a stylish and chunky appearance. Many customers found the shoes comfortable, especially after an initial break-in period. However, the sizing seems inconsistent, with some customers needing to order a size down for the best fit, while others experienced issues with the toe box or heel slipping due to the shoes being too wide or tight. Overall, the shoes appear to be of good quality, but customers may need to experiment with sizing to find the right fit for their feet.
The shoes are absolutely beautiful but size 8 and a half was too big and the 8s kept slipping off my heels. So, I returned them.
no idea
Was this helpful?
00
Verified Purchase
★★★★★★★★★★
November 16, 2026
Classic, Understated, Modern
Size Purchased: 7 1/2
Fit - Width: True to size
Used for: Casual or Every Day
These penny loafers are of excellent quality. The one hesitation I have is that my heel slips out, so I bought a second in a half-size down. Expecting delivery this week. I’m hopin
Xyzz
Xyzz
Was this helpful?
00
★★★★★★★★★★
November 8, 2026
Runs large
Size Purchased: 7
Fit - Width: True to size
Used for: Casual or Every Day
I normally wear a 6 1/2 or 7 in most shoes. I wear a 7 in sneakers. I purchased a size 7 and even with boot socks my heels were coming out when I walked. I used my points to purcha
Gretchen
Yardley Pa
Was this helpful?
10
Verified Purchase
★★★★★★★★★★
November 8, 2026
Disappointing features.
Fit - Width: True to size
Very heavy like boots. Also, no lining-felt rough and clammy. Finally, one shoe felt noticeably larger than the other.
Was this helpful?
10
Verified Purchase
★★★★★★★★★★
November 3, 2026
Fit - Width: True to size
So comfy! Great shoe to wear to work. My go to for a little heel.
Comfy shoe
Was this helpful?
00
★★★★★★★★★★
October 31, 2026
Beautifully made rugged "winter" shoe
Size Purchased: 8 1/2
Fit - Width: Slightly wide
Used for: Casual or Every Day
First, the challenge: getting the correct fit. The shoe runs large, good for my wide foot but I had to return a 9 for an 8.5. The heel width is a bit large, too. BUT, if you unders
Preservationist
Charlotte NC
Was this helpful?
10
Verified Purchase
★★★★★★★★★★
October 30, 2026
Returned twice
Size Purchased: 8
Fit - Width: Slightly narrow
Used for: Casual or Every Day
The quality was good but the sizing was off. I am a size 8 and they were so big they were flopping off. I returned them for a size 7. Those ended up being so painful at the end of
Janet
Quincy MA
Was this helpful?
01
★★★★★★★★★★
October 19, 2026
Too long
Size Purchased: 8
Fit - Width: True to size
Used for: Casual or Every Day
Ordered the size I have always worn, but the toe box extended at least an inch past my big toe.
Sheilagirl
Knoxville TN
Was this helpful?
20
★★★★★★★★★★
October 6, 2026
Classic
Size Purchased: 9
Fit - Width: True to size
Used for: Travel, Relaxing, Casual or Every Day
I was lucky enough to go to a store and get my foot measured to get my right size and width. I wear them all the time - with slacks and jeans and seem to be my go to pair of shoes
classyrobbie
PA
Was this helpful?
40
Verified Purchase
★★★★★★★★★★
May 5, 2026
Perfect Office Shoe
Fit - Width: True to size
The shoes are comfortable and perfect for the office. Suggest wearing w/ regular socks, not stockings.
none
Was this helpful?
50
Verified Purchase
★★★★★★★★★★
March 23, 2026
Fit - Width: True to size
I wear it often and it really holds up well. Great quality.
Jamie
Was this helpful?
00
Verified Purchase
★★★★★★★★★★
February 23, 2026
Heel Slips
Size Purchased: 9 1/2
Fit - Width: True to size
Used for: Casual or Every Day
I love the look, the width is great, but I’ve tried 3 different sizes. The heel slips on all 3. At this point, I’ve worn them outside so I’m stuck with them. Frustrating and expen
Columbus, OH
Was this helpful?
80
Verified Purchase
★★★★★★★★★★
January 22, 2026
1/2 sizes matter especially for the high price
Size Purchased: 8
Fit - Width: Slightly wide
Used for: Casual or Every Day
I'm a 7 1/2 and I had to go up a half size to an eight and they were very uncomfortable hurt my feet
Laurie
CT
Was this helpful?
70
★★★★★★★★★★
January 6, 2026
excellent
Size Purchased: 8
Fit - Width: True to size
Used for: Casual or Every Day
These shoes are excellent. Yes, they run a bit big, but their natural rubber grip, higher profile sole and solid construction are wonderful. Nice sturdy leather and stylish. I h
EAPboz
Bozeman
Was this helpful?
40
Verified Purchase
★★★★★★★★★★
December 14, 2025
Interesting Fit
Size Purchased: 9
Fit - Width: Slightly wide
Used for: Casual or Every Day
I'm not sure I am keeping these shoes yet. They do run large. I want to like them but the fit is off a bit. Tried my actual size; sent those back after just trying one shoe on. Got
Bean Customer
Was this helpful?
61
Verified Purchase
★★★★★★★★★★
December 13, 2025
Great Shoe/Size Down
Size Purchased: 8
Fit - Width: True to size
Used for: Casual or Every Day
Love the rubber sole, leather uppers, but it is sized a whole size too big, requiring a long trip to the store to exchange.
Golden Colorado
Was this helpful?
40
★★★★★★★★★★
December 9, 2025
Very Nice Shoe
Size Purchased: 8 1/2
Fit - Width: True to size
Used for: Casual or Every Day
Shoe quality is great. Nice leather and rugged sole. I wear an 8 or 8.5 shoe. I first bought the size 8, because I saw comments that the shoe size ran big. My big toe hit the fr
Deb R
Central Florida
Was this helpful?
81
★★★★★★★★★★
October 27, 2025
Great shoes!
Size Purchased: 10
Fit - Width: True to size
I don’t understand the negative comments about these loafers, you can’t ask for anything more, they are comfortable, stylish and well made. These shoes are timeless, go with so man
Nikki
Virginia Beach Va
Was this helpful?
125
Verified Purchase
★★★★★★★★★★
October 25, 2025
Excellent quality; weird fit.
Size Purchased: 7 1/2
Fit - Width: Too wide
Great quality but the fit is odd. The heel was way too wide for me. Too bad because I really wanted to keep them but was worried about getting a blister.
TN
Was this helpful?
80
Verified Purchase
★★★★★★★★★★
October 25, 2025
Not comfortable
Size Purchased: 7
Fit - Width: True to size
Used for: Casual or Every Day
I tried these on in store and they fit great! I ordered them to be shipped to my home as in store did not have my size. The shoes I received were so uncomfortable and worlds differ
Response from L.L.Bean
October 29, 2025
By L.L. Bean Customer Service Team
We're sorry to hear that the shoes you received didn’t match the comfort of the pair you tried on in-store. A member of our team will reach out to you to provide assistance.
Welcome to llbean.com! We use cookies and other technologies to provide you with the best possible experience. Check out our privacy policy to learn more.