Skip to main content

It's time to upgrade your browser

Your current browser is no longer supported on llbean.com. Please upgrade to one of the following for a smoother, safer shopping experience with us:

L.L.Bean Men's Stonington Plain-Toe Oxford Shoes With Water-Resistant Leather

Customer Reviews for L.L.Bean Men's Stonington Plain-Toe Oxford Shoes With Water-Resistant Leather

View Product Details

Customer Reviews

4.6 out of 5
★★★★★★★★★★
931 Ratings

What customers say:

The Stonington Oxford shoes are generally well-received by customers. The majority find them to be very comfortable, suitable for all-day wear, and of high quality in terms of leather and construction. Many describe the shoes as stylish and classic in appearance. While a few customers experienced minor issues like laces coming undone or the fit feeling slightly too wide, the overall consensus is that these are excellent, durable, and well-made shoes.

AI Generated from customer reviews.
Verified Purchase
★★★★★★★★★★
November 16, 2026
Underwhelming
Fit - Width: True to size
Not as comfortable as I had hoped. Lots of walking resulted in sore feet and blisters.
Amtrak Tripper

Was this helpful?

00
Verified Purchase
★★★★★★★★★★
November 11, 2026
Stonington Oxford shoe Men's (over 65)
Fit - Width: True to size
Nice shoe, fits good, comfortable surrounding inside. Nice leather Outside and appearance. Outside Bottom Sole a bit harder than I would like. Enough tread. Inside bottom sole is
CCwashashore

Was this helpful?

00
Verified Purchase
★★★★★★★★★★
November 4, 2026
Lace & Leather
Size Purchased: 11 1/2
Fit - Width: True to size
Used for: Casual or Every Day
It is a nice and comfortable shoe. NYC walking approved. The couple of things which are really annoying is that the lace keeps getting untied and the quality of leather used in the
Waseeq
illinois

Was this helpful?

00
★★★★★★★★★★
October 28, 2026
I love these shoes
Size Purchased: 8
Fit - Width: True to size
Used for: Casual or Every Day
I bought these dark cocoa nubuck leather shoes cause they remind me of the L.L.Bean shoes my dad always used to wear. The only thing better would be if you could get them with a b
Brucemit
CA

Was this helpful?

10
★★★★★★★★★★
October 28, 2026
Good Shoe
Size Purchased: 14
Fit - Width: True to size
Used for: Casual or Every Day
Good shoe, lasted 2 years before the tread worn down to a smooth surface, I thinks this is reasonable. Laces are still in good condition and leather tough. These are my daily work
TechConsumer
WI

Was this helpful?

00
Verified Purchase
★★★★★★★★★★
October 23, 2026
Handsome Shoes
Fit - Width: True to size
I am very happy with the look of these shoes, versatile that can be worn anywhere. I found the size slightly larger than expected but with heavy socks fit well. The shoes do not

Was this helpful?

00
★★★★★★★★★★
October 22, 2026
Laces are much too long!!!
Size Purchased: 14
Fit - Width: True to size
Used for: Casual or Every Day
The laces on these shoes are ridiculously too long. I am cutting them back by 10 inches!! What a bother and waste of money to have to buy laces that fit the shoes,
Response from L.L.Bean
November 3, 2026
By L.L.Bean Customer Service Team
Thank you for sharing your feedback. We apologize for the issue you encountered. A member of our team will be in touch to help resolve this.
Long time customer
South Portland

Was this helpful?

00
Verified Purchase
★★★★★★★★★★
October 22, 2026
Size Purchased: 7
Fit - Width: True to size
Used for: Casual or Every Day
Material is comfortable and it fits well. True size!
Star
Boston

Was this helpful?

00
★★★★★★★★★★
October 18, 2026
Size Purchased: 10
Fit - Width: True to size
Used for: Hiking
Bought this shoe in April 2026 and the uppers are tough and took a couple of weeks to break in. The fit was great. Very comfortable after break in however the soles are wearing out
Response from L.L.Bean
November 1, 2026
By L.L.Bean Customer Service Team
We're sorry to hear that the Stonington Oxfords did not quite meet expectations. A member of our team will be reaching out shortly.
Limin
Virgin Islands

Was this helpful?

00
Verified Purchase
★★★★★★★★★★
October 17, 2026
Great shoes
Fit - Width: True to size
Bought very similar shoes from LLBean many years ago that are still good. At the flag store and couldn't resist getting a second pair.
Mr Kip

Was this helpful?

00
Verified Purchase
★★★★★★★★★★
September 26, 2026
Very Comfortable!
Size Purchased: 10 1/2
Fit - Width: True to size
Used for: Travel, Casual or Every Day
These are comfortable and versatile. I like that I can wear them with jeans or khakis.
Pennypoo
Maryland

Was this helpful?

00
Verified Purchase
★★★★★★★★★★
September 24, 2026
Disappointed
Size Purchased: 9 1/2
Fit - Width: Too wide
Used for: Casual or Every Day
It's a handsome, sturdy shoe, but I purchased it in size 9 1/2 D and found that this size was too narrow. So I exchanged it for a size 9 1/2E. The shoes arrived a few days ago, and
Response from L.L.Bean
October 3, 2026
By L.L.Bean Customer Service
We're sorry you're having trouble finding the right fit. If you haven't already, we'd be happy to help explore other sizing options or styles that may work better for you.
DanK
New York, NY

Was this helpful?

00
Verified Purchase
★★★★★★★★★★
September 21, 2026
You can swim in these.
Size Purchased: 10 1/2
Fit - Width: Too wide
Used for: Casual or Every Day
I normally take a 10.5 medium width shoe..This same shoe fit so loosely that I returned it after a mere walk to my car in the LL Bean parking lot.
Washington DC and Norway Maine.

Was this helpful?

00
Verified Purchase
★★★★★★★★★★
September 20, 2026
Great shoe
Fit - Width: True to size
This is my second pair. The first pair has been excellent in fit, comfort, and durability so I purchased another pair while they were still available.

Was this helpful?

00
Verified Purchase
★★★★★★★★★★
September 3, 2026
Not that comfortable
Fit - Width: True to size
Returned the shoes. Nice looking, but not comfortable.
GEB1

Was this helpful?

00
Verified Purchase
★★★★★★★★★★
September 3, 2026
Well made
Fit - Width: True to size
Nice looking shoe, I get complimented all the time from my daughter.

Was this helpful?

00
★★★★★★★★★★
September 1, 2026
Nice shoes exept soles wore out too quickly
Size Purchased: 11
Fit - Width: True to size
Used for: Casual or Every Day
I bought these to wear in the office only. The top looks great still but the soles are worn through after a year.
Response from L.L.Bean
September 5, 2026
By L.L.Bean Customer Service Team
We're sorry to learn these shoes did not hold up as you expected. We want you to be satisfied with how our products perform. You do have a full year to return an item to us, and you are welcome to return items that have been worn. Get in touch if you need assistance with a return.
TJ VT
Vermont

Was this helpful?

30
★★★★★★★★★★
August 19, 2026
They started out great….
Size Purchased: 12
Fit - Width: True to size
Used for: Casual or Every Day
I bought these shoes about a month and a half ago. I liked them. They took a little breaking in but not significant. Then today I noticed the soul was coming away from the shoe at
Verne
Haverhill

Was this helpful?

20
★★★★★★★★★★
August 10, 2026
Great Shoe for Foot Pain
Size Purchased: 13
Fit - Width: True to size
Used for: Travel, Casual or Every Day
I suffer from Plantar Factitious and I needed a pair of shoes that were water resistant. I choose this pair because they are LL Bean quality, they haves removable insoles and can s
Blair
Utah

Was this helpful?

22
Verified Purchase
★★★★★★★★★★
June 27, 2026
Great buy
Size Purchased: 13
Fit - Width: True to size
Used for: Casual or Every Day
Well priced, very simple and functional shoe, my everyday work shoes now
Mffi607
Irvine Ca

Was this helpful?

01

Viewing 1 - 20 of 300