FREE SHIPPING with $75 Purchase - or - FREE with the L.L.Bean Mastercard 
‹ Back to L.L.Bean Women's Signature Cotton Fisherman Sweater, Fair Isle Crewneck
Customer Reviews for L.L.Bean Women's Signature Cotton Fisherman Sweater, Fair Isle Crewneck
View Product DetailsCustomer Reviews
What customers say:
Customers overwhelmingly praise this sweater for its exceptional quality, warmth, and charming design. The heavyweight cotton construction feels durable and substantial, with vibrant colors and detailed cable stitching that reviewers describe as premium craftsmanship. The playful nautical and seasonal motifs—reindeer, ducks, anchors, fair isle patterns—are widely loved, with many reporting spontaneous compliments. Most find it true to size with a flattering, slightly loose fit, though some note it runs large or has shorter sleeves. A few mention discrepancies between images and actual embroidery details, or report strong perfume odors. Overall, most customers consider it a worthwhile favorite piece.
AI Generated from customer reviews. Filter:
88 Reviews
Sort:
October 3, 2026
It’s a conundrum
Weight: 110-120 lbs
Height: 5'2"
Size Purchased: X-Small
Used for: Casual or Every Day
Adore this sweater. Petite xs, generously sized. Color is perfect, mine has the golden retrievers, looks super cute with my short tan suede skirt. But, I’m in Southern California.
Southern California
Was this helpful?
00
Verified Purchase
September 28, 2026
Beautiful
Weight: 120-130 lbs
Height: 5'2"
Size Purchased: X-Large
Used for: Casual or Every Day
I found this at an LLBEAN clearance center and I can’t believe it was marked down. The quality is top notch it feels like a hand knit sweater, it’s very heavy and warm. Fits true t
Woodbury CT
Was this helpful?
10
September 27, 2026
It is a nice sweater, but in need of a patch
Weight: 140-150 lbs
Height: 5'8"
Size Purchased: Medium
Used for: Travel, Relaxing, Casual or Every Day
I loved the style and design of this sweater so much, and waited a long time for it to go on sale. I'm a first-time shopper, so I was really excited about a 100% cotton holiday swe
Was this helpful?
10
Verified Purchase
September 25, 2026
Great knit!
Size Purchased: Large
Used for: Casual or Every Day
Nice wt beautiful knit true to size only wish there were more colors and more patterns.
Ny
Was this helpful?
00
Verified Purchase
September 16, 2026
Beautiful!!!
Weight: 150-160 lbs
Height: 5'2"
Size Purchased: Medium
Used for: Relaxing, Casual or Every Day, Cross-Country Skiing, Camping, Hiking
Absolutely stunning sweater. Perfect w a thin jean shirt underneath for a layered look The stitching is great quality. So very warm and cozy. I have only worn once and got tons
Butler pa
Was this helpful?
11
Verified Purchase
September 16, 2026
Absolutely Beautiful!!!!!
Weight: 150-160 lbs
Height: 5'2"
Size Purchased: Medium
Used for: Travel, Relaxing, Casual or Every Day, Cross-Country Skiing
Omg LlBean has done it again with this beautiful sweater. Bought it a little bigger as to wear a little shirt underneath. The quality of the material is unsurpassed. I am able to
Butler pa
Was this helpful?
11
September 10, 2026
Great sweater!
Weight: 130-140 lbs
Height: 5'2"
Size Purchased: Small
Used for: Casual or Every Day
What a good deal on sale! Hesitated because if loon imagery, but imagery is very subtle. Heavy, lovely pink. Fits very well-not too big or too small.
Walworth, NY
Was this helpful?
10
August 21, 2026
Beautiful sweater!!!
Weight: 150-160 lbs
Height: 5'2"
Size Purchased: Medium
Used for: Travel, Relaxing, Casual or Every Day, Cross-Country Skiing
Omg this sweater is so cozy and stunning. Per usual the exceptional quality and coziness of this sweater is unsurpassed. Beautiful color and workmanship. It is a bit oversized (
Butler Pa
Was this helpful?
22
Verified Purchase
August 14, 2026
Weight: 140-150 lbs
Height: 5'3"
Size Purchased: Medium
Used for: Casual or Every Day
I have a yellow labrador retriever so this sweater has been on my buy list. It is weighty and looks well-knitted. I bought in July so will have to wait a while to wear it.
Omaha, NE
Was this helpful?
20
Verified Purchase
July 29, 2026
Do not waste your money.
The sweater is extremely heavy, scratchy and overall uncomfortable.
Response from L.L.Bean
August 4, 2026
By L.L.Bean Customer Service Team
We're sorry the quality was not what you were expecting. You can return or exchange within 1 year with proof of purchase. A member of our team will be reaching out to you.
Was this helpful?
53
July 10, 2026
Cute sweater
Weight: 200-210 lbs
Height: 5'7"
Size Purchased: 1X
Used for: Travel, Relaxing, Casual or Every Day
I bought the 1X and I am usually an XL/XXL/1X (bust 45, waist 35). This fits nicely. I might say the sleeves are a little long, but they look cute cuffed. It is definitely a bulky
Texas
Was this helpful?
50
Verified Purchase
June 19, 2026
Patterned sweater
This is a beautiful sweater.
Sadly, I probably won't wear it often as it's very heavy and scratchy.
I tried to soften it by rewashing, but it didn't work.
Response from L.L.Bean
June 22, 2026
By L.L. Bean Customer Service Team
We're sorry the sweater was not what you were expecting. You can return or exchange within 1 year with proof of purchase. A member of our team will be reaching out to you.
Was this helpful?
51
Verified Purchase
May 7, 2026
Fun wintery sweater
Weight: 130-140 lbs
Height: 5'5"
Size Purchased: Large
Used for: Travel, Relaxing, Casual or Every Day, Cross-Country Skiing, Camping
Beautiful well-made substantial sweater. I've been eyeing this one since it first came out. A recent sale plus % off put it in my price range, but my size M was sold out. I bought
WV
Was this helpful?
130
Verified Purchase
April 12, 2026
love it
Weight: 140-150 lbs
Height: 5'2"
Size Purchased: Large
Used for: Travel, Relaxing, Casual or Every Day
I’ve always wanted one of these fisherman sweaters! It is so warm & comfy! It washed well. I got the large, 150 lbs 5’2” & am able to layer a tshirt & a thinner (merino wool) sweat
Was this helpful?
101
Verified Purchase
April 5, 2026
A woman's Fisherman's sweater
Love the color, a rich brown, the size was good. My only problem was the heaviness. It surly will keep me warm!
Was this helpful?
60
Verified Purchase
March 25, 2026
Love this Sweater
Weight: 170-180 lbs
Height: 5'7"
Size Purchased: Large
Used for: Relaxing
Really enjoying my sweater! Nice and warm! I am so glad I decided to order!
Spokane, WA
Was this helpful?
50
Verified Purchase
March 21, 2026
Perfect in every way.
Love it! Fits perfectly, soft texture and so comfortable. Just my style.
Was this helpful?
30
Verified Purchase
March 20, 2026
Cute, but odd fit
I really love the looks of the ski themed sweater but it took three trys to get one that came anywhere near fitting my 5'2"", 110 lb frame. I have an older fisherman's sweater in a
Was this helpful?
31
Verified Purchase
March 20, 2026
Signature Cotton Fisherman Crewneck Novelty Sweate
Love it! It fits well and is made well. Very atractive.
Was this helpful?
40
Verified Purchase
March 18, 2026
lovely sweater, lovely embroidery yet heavy
Lovely sweater, well made, great embroidery but it is "heavy" in weight to wear; not really comfy.
Was this helpful?
21
Viewing 1 - 20 of 88
‹ Back to L.L.Bean Women's Signature Cotton Fisherman Sweater, Fair Isle Crewneck