Rated 4 out of 5 by VermonterMaineer Love these boots all except for one problem
The heel is covered with strips of leather and it is falling apart. I am going to have to return them but I am waiting until the end of the season because I love them so much. They are perfect except for that one issue. I paid way too much money for them to have them fall apart so quickly.
February 19, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by alilace not impressed
I love LLBean boots. I had a pair of the deerfield boots for a few years until they finally fell apart from so much use (and they stopped making them at this point). These boots are great except for one big issue. A month after I began wearing them the sole, especially the heel, began wearing down and falling apart. They don't get as much use, as I recently moved to a warmer climate, so I don't understand why this happened. I love LLBean because of the quality of their products, but these just weren't up to the standard. I was very disappointed.
January 11, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by Pachelbel9 Love these boots!
I eyed these boots all last fall/winter. I was waiting for them to go on sale, and by the time they did, they were out of my size for the season. I was so bummed! So, when this year's boots came out, I knew I had to buy some immediately. I tried on the 2013 version, but It was obvious something changed this year, and I just didn't love them as much. Thankfully, one day I saw the 2012 version in stock on the website, so I jumped on them. I've worn them every day for a week, and I love them. So much so that I ordered a backup pair for the day these boots die (which I suspect will be a while from now).
A note about sizing - when I tries these on in the store last year, they were so narrow I decided I needed a 8.5 wide. Since only the M was available this year, I took a chance with those. Oddly, they fit fine. I don't know if they modified the cut mid-year or not, but if so it's for the better. The reviews for these boots last year all lamented the narrow cut.
November 2, 2013
Rated 5 out of 5 by CosmicBlue Ready for Cold Weather
I searched for a long time before deciding to order this boot. The boots I tried from a department store looked similar, but did not have the same quality these do at a similar price. These are made with substantial leather, good padding in the footbed, and a thicker sole. I have a 14" calf and ordered the size 8 1/2 medium. The buckle at the top is adjustable, so I am able to change it to wear with jeans or bare leg with the same comfort. I wore them around the house for two days to make sure....decided I really love wearing them.
October 27, 2013
Rated 5 out of 5 by Iloveclothes Mother tested, kid approved!
The ultimate reviews came from my kids. From my 11 y/o daughter, "Oh my gosh, those are so cool! I love your outfit!" They even caused my 14 y/o son to look twice and say, "Wow. Boots." If that isn't a glowing review, I don't know what is.
These boots are the perfect blend of casual #wearing with jeans or cords# and dressy #wearing with a dress or skirt# without being trendy and out of style in two days. A sturdy sole and heel means rain or slush won't be a problem. I've worn them to work and to the stables and they work great at both places.
I wear 8 1/2 and that is the size I purchased in the Dark Sienna; ample space for thicker socks and the buckles on the tops of the boots allow for accomodation of either thicker pants or thinner tights. Not too long to cause slipping when I walk. They seem only slightly bunchy at the ankles. The zipper glides with ease.
I love them. LL Bean, please provide these in black. Please. Please. Please.
October 25, 2013
Rated 4 out of 5 by TerryinWA Quality boot. Med width runs narrow. True to size
I purchased these boots last winter and returned them because the stitching on the zipper was coming undone. I am so sorry I did because my size was sold out! I want them back and would gladly pay to have them re-stitched! Sad, sad shopper. Tried this year's style and was not impressed with the styling. Please make this boot available again!!
I rated them a 4 because they were so narrow in width. I really look for evaluators to comment on your normal size and the adjustments you had to make in your exchanges to get the correct size. It allows me to make the best choice the FIRST time I order!
September 8, 2013
Rated 5 out of 5 by surfcitygal2 Most comfortable boot I own!
These boots are the most comfortable boots I own. Went on 2 trips to Europe this year & took them both times (it was worth the space they took in my suitcase!)
I wore them all over Italy in March. It was a bit rainy on that trip, but the boots kept me cozy & dry.
In May I packed them a gain for a trip to Scotland. Again, they came thru! They were my 'go to' foot wear for the entire trip.
Just purchased a second pair in brown.
They will be one of the first things I pack on my next adventure.
August 1, 2013
Rated 2 out of 5 by swimminlizzy Just not right
I SO desperately wanted to love these boots. I have wanted a pair of tall leather boots for quite some time and these seemed perfect by the description.
I am a big woman: about 5' 10" and around 190 lbs, though pretty well proportioned. A lot of the boots I've tried on are snug around my calves. I generally wear a 10 Wide shoe. These boots were crafted for someone much larger than I am. The footbed seemed just about perfect for me across the instep, but my heel area had a good inch of room. The most bizarre thing was that the ankle area actually bagged and wrinkled around my leg. I had at least an inch of room around the calf with my jeans tucked inside the boots and when I tried them on under a skirt, they felt like they might fall off. The overall effect was sloppy and ill-fitting.
They were also shorter than I would like - the top of the boot came to about 5" below my knee. With the wrinkling ankle area, they slid down even further when I walked around the house.
I kept the boots for several days, trying them on again and again, trying to convince myself that they would work. Eventually I packed them back into the box they came in and noticed that in many places there were scratch marks and it looked like the dye was coming off the leather. I can't imagine how they would do under actual conditions of normal wear.
So, back to the store they go. I am so very disappointed.
March 24, 2013
Rated 4 out of 5 by NativeNewYorker5 Finally a pair of tall boots that fit!
I am a medium tall woman, 5'9" , and through out the years I have had a terrible time finding tall boots that fit. Most regular calf boot's don't zip up. And most wide calf boots have wide ankles that dig into my leg. These fit both my athletic calves ,16 1/2, and my rather normal sized ankles and are the first pair of tall boots I have ever owned.
I really like these boots. I purchased them in the dark brown color. They were a little tight at the ball of the foot at first but with a few wearings they relaxed. I wear regular trouser socks with them, not thick sports socks. They look great with my dresses, skirts and slim fit pants. I wish they came in Black I would buy another pair.
March 9, 2013
Rated 5 out of 5
by jodidesign2 They fit my (big) calves!
I have large calves (17 3/4") and was hesitant about these boots, but was pleasantly surprised when I got them because I had no problem zipping them up... Granted, they are not high boots and fall just below the largest part of the calf, but still - they fit like a glove... I wear an 8.5 and ordered an 8.5 wide - perfect fit... Can't wait to wear them! :)
March 6, 2013