Rated 5 out of 5 by MegaMayhem Love
I debated between the S and XS in this sweater, due to all the frantic reviews decrying it for being insultingly small. I am 5'5" 120 lbs with 30D chest. I went with the XS because I am petite with a short torso and it fits wonderfully. I would definitely not call it fitted - for example, the fabric does sort of puff out at my low back and bunches in places when I bend or twist - basically it fits like a fisherman sweater should, not bulky but substantial and comfy. I did try it on with a button-down underneath and it fit, but it didn't quite look right. The neck is thick and sits a bit higher so you don't see the collar of the shirt anyhow, and the cuffs are snug, so I couldn't really have pulled the shirtsleeves through comfortably. It really looks better on its own in my opinion, so I think I'll wear it with just a basic long-sleeved t-shirt underneath, hair pulled up with some red lipstick and hot cocoa :)
February 13, 2015
Rated 1 out of 5 by mimidoe not fitted
I bought one of these last fall in blue, size XL to accommodate my bust. That sweater is beautifully fitted, chunky, and heavy. After waiting several weeks for a backorder fulfillment, I received the cream one in XL and it is like a different sweater altogether.
It was noticeably lighter in weight than the blue, and knit not nearly as densely. I tried it on and it was huge, falling to my lower hip. I actually laid it out with the blue on top of it and there were several inches difference in all dimensions. I don't believe the blue shrank, as I've only laundered it once and laid it on a rack to air dry.
I'm still trying to decide whether to try the cream in L...I'm afraid the sizing will be off no matter what, and that they'll all lack the dense, chunky knit of my blue...
February 12, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by Seagal31 Best Sweater
I was hesitant about buying my regular size for this sweater due to the other reviews, but i bought my usual size small, and it fits perfect, and i can put a button down shirt under it, so i would say go with your size unless you want it big. I love the way it fits (fitted), and I love the color, and have gotten many compliments on the sweater! It has been my go to sweater this winter!
February 10, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by LindsayOnTheFly Hemingway would be proud
I have been searching for the perfect fisherman's cableknit sweater, and this is it. It is a well-made, heavy sweater with a great fit. I am 5'7" 130 lbs and a medium fits like a glove. There's still room for a collared shirt underneath without looking bulky. The faded characteristic of the navy color gives it a unique, but vintage look. It's also very warm. I love it.
February 5, 2015
Rated 4 out of 5 by MountainTrillian Not very fitted
I bought the S (due to reviews saying this was tiny) and when it arrived it was not tiny. The signature fit wasn't any smaller or more fitted than a normal LL Bean sweater. So I had to return it and order an XS. It fits ok in XS, it is still loose on me but the washed look is a unique effect, it's very warm, and the quality is beyond excellent. I wish it was offered in petite, I am 5' and 100# so the sleeves are long as is the length of the sweater, a petite XS would be 5 stars.
February 4, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by irisheyes789 Simply a great sweater
This is simply a great sweater. I was looking for a sweater with an "Aran hand-knit" look-the signature sweater of the Irish fishermen that is typically made from Irish wool. Authentic Aran hand-knit sweaters, though, tend to be very heavy, bulky and itchy-no matter what size or style. So when I came across this picture, the sweater did not look bulky on the model and actually looked a little fitted. Just what I was looking for. It definitely has a more slender fit to it and it is waist-length, so it doesn't fall far below the belt for a very cute, feminine look. I have a more slender build (5' 6", 125) and the thing fit like a glove. Not much room for anything underneath except a tanktop, which is perfect since the material is heavy enough for warmth, but not too bulky.
The material is not authentic Irish wool (made in China), but that's not entirely a bad thing because it's a very soft material that is not too heavy and itchy. I've worn several times without having to wash and it's really retained its shape. The color is not quite the warm vanilla color of a true Irish wool sweater, it's actually more of a muted off-white. Again, not a bad thing, it is what it is. Overall, just get it. You won't regret it. This is a current, cute alternative to your Irish granny's Aran hand-knit.
January 9, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by Schnauzers Love This Sweater
I just received my sweater, have tried it on and it fits perfectly, looks grand and feels so cozy. I wish it came in additional colors.
December 11, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by StayClassy Great fit, beautiful sweater
I'm 5' 6 140lbs Bra size:32DD/34D Measurements: 36-27-38 and I order a small in the cream color. The sweater is beautiful and warm. I usually wear it with a long sleeve shirt or the signature turtleneck underneath. I have gone out at night with the temps around 25-30 degrees with just a down vest on. It fits me like it does the model. It hits me at the hip bone and is slightly fitted.
November 18, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5 by ar212 Not as shown online
First, the pros: I love the color, and it looks like it would be very warm. The problem: the fit is completely not as shown online. It looks short and fitted. It is NOT fitted. It's not even short. They cinched it on the model. (Maybe I should have ordered 2 sizes smaller.) This is every big sweater you wore in the 80s. It's going back; I don't dress like that anymore. 3 stars for quality only, fit gets a 0.
November 14, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5 by LikesOldStyleQualityBest quite nice
I really liked this sweater although returned because I wasn't happy with the color. I have the washed blue on backorder and will keep it I do believe unless I do not like the color for some reason or if the fit is different. My only reservation about the sweater is that it will not wash and wear well?. It looks like no matter how careful one is, and I am extremely careful with my clothing, the threads would shred within a short time. I do however recommend because my concerns are only guesses at this point.
November 13, 2014