Rated 5 out of 5 by Frommers Order a size down
The instructions were incorrect, at least for me. I wear a 10, and the 10s were huge. Got a 9. They fit well.
April 18, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by mamaw3and2 Excellent for support, comfort, fit!
I just purchased my second pair of these sandals. I have to wear shoes w/support (Clark, etc.) and these are the only sandals I have found that have the support/cushioning and comfort level for me. They are great for walking, don't make my legs tired, and have stayed looking great which is saying something for shoes that get a lot of wear. They are fine for casual dresses, wearing with jeans or shorts. LOVE these sandals, and hope they are never discontinued!
April 12, 2015
Rated 4 out of 5 by Busyoldlady Perfect for narrow feet
I just purchased my 6th pair and wear them year round. Yes, the ridge at the ball of the foot is a problem but solved by having it filed down at the local upholstery shop. Very comfortable and great foot support. I did not give it a 5 due to the ridge.
March 27, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by Coach2015 Great sandles
I work as a professional swim coach and wanted something that was comfortable, lightweight, dried quick and had great traction for long meets.I love these sandals. I have had them for 3 years of being doused in chlorine daily while deck running. Although still in good shape I am getting a second pair so I can leave one at the pool.
February 13, 2015
Rated 4 out of 5 by MaineRaised Great sandals, only one dissapointment...
I love these shoes, they feel great, they fit perfectly, except for the strap over the back of the heel. The heel strap has no purpose as the design of it is too low for any heel. When the sandal is on, the heel strap rests on the sole of the shoe..how odd!! It will not stay on even after pulling it up multiple times, and when I walk it slips off. The strap over my foot is snug and is not what's causing the heel strap problem.
I will have to get used to it, I don't think it's enough to make me return them as of yet.
L.L.Bean, please fix this problem to make this sandal amazing!
As for size, I always wear a half size smaller in heels from my actual sneaker size, so I got these in my "heel" size and they fit perfect.
January 23, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by BklynLori Boothbay Sandals are my FAVS!
I bought these maybe in 2013 (possibly '12), in a darker brown color, 9 1/2. I <3 THESE! they are definitely my most favorite everyday summer sandal, compared to another mall brand which I also buy. I have a medium width foot, the fit is perfect, and it's nice that the velcro straps, which in no way detract from its looks, can be adjusted. TOTALLY RECOMMEND!
January 20, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by HarperCreekGirl Awesome sandle!
I have so many arch and ankle issues, it's difficult to find a really comfortable shoe. Then I found this Boothbay shoe. I just ordered my 3rd pair! They are the most amazing shoe I have ever had on my foot! Since I wear them everyday, I have 2 pairs, and just ordered my 3rd because they were on sale.
January 7, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by Tassigirl Soooooo comfortable!
I have always been hesitant to order shoes by mail but I took a punt on these when they were on sale because of the great reviews and the ability to adjust the straps in multiple places. I am so glad I did: these are the most comfortable shoes I have ever owned in my 60 something years!
They are incredibly light but very supportive along the foot bed. In fact they have become my "go to" shoe for when I have to stand for any length of time at home...no matter what the season (in cold weather I wear them with socks). I was so happy with my first pair a couple of years ago that I bought 2 more in the following summer.
December 20, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by CrazySpaniard Good fit, very comfortable
I like these sandals a lot. I have a very narrow foot but it's a size 11 which usually means I end up with shoes that are the right length but way too roomy for my foot. These were the case but they have 3 straps that you can adjust, so once I adjusted all of them, my feet were snug as bugs and I don't have to worry about my feet flopping around inside the sandals when I walk. I bought them for a trip in Indonesia where it'll be rainy season but really hot. I wanted something that could handle the water but still be light and airy for my hot feet. I ordered the cream-colored ones, but would have liked to have ordered the ones that appear on the picture, which is a very soft blue with grey trim. That color was displayed on the model but was not available to choose from.
November 16, 2014
Rated 1 out of 5 by JaneNY Boothbay sandals, non leather
I ordered the non leather one the fitting was good. It looked nice and looked comfortable. However, it had sharp edges on the inside that gave my many blisters after wearing them for one day.
October 29, 2014