Rated 2 out of 5áby knitter Almost, not quite, right
Nice material, nice color. I received this shirt as a gift last Christmas and have worn it quite a bit. The first button down from the collar is too far down. Buttoning the collar isn't always comfortable. Not buttoning the collar leaves the top gaping open. You can see this on the model in the Bean picture. It's just not a nice fit, and I've never gotten used to it. I probably won't buy this shirt again until LLBean redesigns it to move the buttons up and maybe add another button. Spend another two cents and do it right. This used to be a really nice, well-fitting shirt.
August 13, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5áby Ferris Cuddly Fall or Winter Over Shirt
I have two of these shirts, which I love. Living in Southern Arizona, they are perfect for mild winters. Every thing is very casual in Tucson, these shirts are perfect for going out for dinner or a walk in the desert.
The fabric is soft and they colors are vibrant. The shirts look great with a t-shirt underneath. My only complaint is they need ironing after being washed and dried.
Thank you, LLBean
June 17, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5áby coldincalif Scotch Plaid Shirt
The last few items I've bought on L.L. Bean have run small. I saw this shirt and it was available in Red/White Menzies in size 1X. Normally, I do not wear this size but I decided to order it anyway and see what I get. What I got was a HUGE shirt that seemed enormous in size but I decided to wash it and see what I ended up with.
What I ended up with is a perfectly fitting shirt! My husband even commented that he thought it hung well on me and was flattering. I was so pleased that I came back to this site to see if they had any more available and yes, they had one left in the color Black Stewart size 1X and I ordered this yesterday and am now waiting to receive it. Will be using these much like I do the "Big Shirts" sold by L.L. Bean.
This is a quality made shirt out of Portuguese flannel and yes, it shrinks. That is what flannel tends to do -- shrink.
So my advice is to buy one of these and by all means DO SIZE UP and you'll be happy as can be.
It did not bleed out, etc. while being washed in cold water and also was dried in a regular dryer completely which likely caused a lot of the needed shrinkage.
Thanks for a great shirt that I'm sure will last many years L.L. Bean! :)
April 18, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5áby anynamewilldo Love my shirt, however it does shrink
I almost returned my shirt as it was too big,but after washing it it became just right.
April 4, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5áby Skye1 Flannel Shirt
I purchased both the Gray Stewart and the Black Stewart. I am pleased with my purchase. I found that the Gray Stewart ran a bit small and needed to order up a size. The Gray Stewart showed pilling after washing even though I hung it up while still damp. The Black Stewart still looks brand new and runs true to size, very comfortable shirt and thrilled that the arms are long enough. I don't like a button down collar so I unbuttoned it and removed the round white paper on the inside of the button with a cuticle scissor.
March 26, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5áby BigBadScientist Well made, looks great, fit not quite perfect
A really nice, warm, and well-made shirt. My only complaint is minor, and it's about the fit. I'm nearly 5'9" and a properly-fitted 36H, so while an XL is great in the length/arms/shoulders, it's boxy in the body and pulls slightly across the chest (ie, the dreaded button gap). A slightly fuller cut in the front combined with a more tapered fit along the body would have made this the perfect 3-season shirt.
March 21, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5áby lastMinuteOrder Scotch Plaid Shirt, petite size
Ordered a Women's Petite Small in Scotch Plaid Shirt. It fits well; the arms are not too long, which can be a problem in my fit. It is soft, washes well and has not shrunk in 3 washes. Warm and comfy. Would order another next winter and give as gifts. Would like to see more feminine color palette.
March 16, 2014
Rated 3 out of 5áby mgmary great shirt, made a bit small
all my other shirts were perfect, but this one is a bit small. My arms are small, and the shirt is snug under the arms. I should have returned, but threw packing away, because all other shirts fit perfectly. my fault, but order up 1 size.
March 12, 2014
Rated 4 out of 5áby chilimama Great Find!
Finally! Flannel shirts that look good and feel great, wash and wear well. Very little shrinking, though Kennedy pilled a little after washing, but not the Black Stewart.
White facing on inside of collar buttons a mystery and hard to get rid of.
A suggestion would be to have one more button added down the front for fortification. One more button down the front would eliminate gapping at the bust and midriff, something cherished by full figured women.
All in all, though, a great find. Thanks Bean!
March 7, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5áby ohiograndmaof6 Perfect.
The shirt is perfect. Just what I expected. My favorite cold weather shirt. looks and feels great.
March 5, 2014