Rated 4 out of 5 by Goodhue Warm & Comfortable
A perfect sweater for a cold day! It's rather bulky but I guess that that's what makes it so good at shutting out the cold.It also blocks the wind fairly well for a sweater.It's lining is comfortable and keeps the thick wool from being itchy. The only thing that kept me from giving it five stars is that it's a bit saggy at the bottom. ~ A good,warm sweater for those really cold days.
December 5, 2013
Rated 5 out of 5 by VAFiddler Warmest of All
Purchased this in charcoal for my husband last winter. He loves it and insists it's the warmest sweater or jacket he owns. I'm buying another one in another color for this Christmas!
We did try the greenish color but it didn't work for his wardrobe.
Wonderful quality, as always, and a nice alternative to the sportscoat.
November 30, 2013
Rated 1 out of 5 by R1234C Not well made
I'm wearing this sweater now. But I have had continuing problems with the zipper and both pockets have started to unravel. I now wear it only when I am working in the yard and no one will see me.
And this review procedure is too cumbersome!!!
October 16, 2013
Rated 5 out of 5 by hoosierboy Awesome
This is a awesome, fine fitting,great fabric with awesome style don't let this get away kind of sweater that you come across perhaps only once in your life and you better get your hands on one or you will be really mad at yourself when someone you know starts bragging about the great awesome sweater they bought after reading a review on this website and the guy just could not say enough good things about it so they knew that guy was a wise man speaking the truth about something that would change his life.Then you will see it and touch it and feel like an idiot for not taking a strangers advice on clothes,then you will eat tacos for depression and get fat and angry about that sweater.Oh.did I mention the Taupe color is really nice and the lambswool is very soft too.PS; Women like soft wool on a guy,trust me.
April 2, 2013
Rated 5 out of 5 by wejm Just what I wanted
and keeps me warm in these cold days.
January 23, 2013
Rated 5 out of 5 by midwestkat Super warm sweater Need More Colors
My husband and father have been wearing one of these sweaters just about every day since last fall. They both say it is their warmest sweater and love having the pockets for cold hands. After being worn day after day, the sweaters still look great. I bought the first ones in 2011 and got the other colors this past fall, 2012.
They now have all the colors and I am making a request for some new shades for this coming year. I would love to get this for them in navy, black or nice evergreen/hunter green. I tried the wool sweater lined in flannel, which my dad liked, but he prefers the wool/fleece combination. Navy, black, green??? Please. Great sweater.
January 14, 2013
Rated 5 out of 5 by Cardiweaer So warm
I absolutely love this sweater. So much so I have bought two. They keep you warm in all types of weather. I rarely wear a coat now as this sweater comforts you even below freezing. The wool of so tightly woven, the wind doesn't blow through it and the sherpa lining is comfortable and warm.
They have warn like a tank, showing almost no wear in two years. And like I said, I wear them a lot.
December 25, 2012
Rated 5 out of 5 by JasonsScotchReviews Rugged!
I have owned this cardigan for 6 years and worn it every winter on a daily basis (well actually when I get home from work and on weekends). Anyhow, I remember when they launched this product and let me tell you, today it is like the day I bought it. No sign of wear and tear on the exterior. Elbows are immaculate.
Certainly the sherpa lining shows some wear on the interior.
What is really impressive about this cardigan is that it often doubles as a winter jacket on nippy days. It is breathable for around the house, but you can then go outside on a cold day and feel warm.
December 13, 2012
Rated 2 out of 5 by fresh Super except for pilling
My husband loved this sweater b/c of its warmth but we had to return it because of pilling. He stopped wearing it out of the house because it was such a mess. If this problem could be corrected, it would be a terrific sweather.
November 24, 2012
Rated 2 out of 5 by Bombadil Color blind?
My biggest complaint about the sweater is the color. I bought the deep loden heather. It was anything but, more like a brown. Definitely not like the deep loden heather in their lambswool sweater.
November 15, 2012