Rated 5 out of 5 by DoctorGonzo Above and beyond
I will briefly join the chorus and say that you need to do your measurements VERY carefully when deciding on what size reel case to get and that they run a tad small (mostly in height). Aside from that minor concern, these reel cases are fantastic! The leather and canvas are supple and already feel familiar in your hand from the first day; I expect them to age beautifully. There is a nice thick bed of shearling inside and they close up tight with the zippers. The piece of leather with the LL bean logo is also raised off of the canvas and allows you to hook it to a clip, carabineer, rope, or put a tag on it to label what reel you have inside; which is what I did since I have more than one of these great cases. These are much higher quality and will provide a lot more padding and protection to your reels than all but the most expensive OEM cases and are ridiculously affordable. This should be the first purchase you make after a new reel and will definitely be mine from now on.
January 14, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by Jifigz Nice Case for a Great Price
I ordered this to mainly stow away my reel in a backpack and keep it relatively protected while I backpack in to more remote streams. For the money, this case is awesome. I love the vintage look of the case. I will echo what others have said as the case seems to run a little small as compared to advertised dimensions, but the small does fit my Okuma Sierra 4/5 but it is tight. I don't doubt that it will stretch a tad over time and be fine, and given that it is a 4/5 size reel I can understand it barely fitting. This would hold a 2/3 reel perfectly and barely holds the 4/5, but still holds it, so I feel that the small sizing is appropriate. I am going to buy more of these or I will try out there Kennebec covers. Good stuff though.
January 5, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 Excellent sharpening stone case
I bought the small size of this to carry a Lansky puck-type axe sharpening stone in my backpack. It's like they were made for each other. The quality of this case is impeccable and the traditional look pleasing. Highly recommend.
August 6, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by SavageLawyer Top Quality (with a small caveat)
As others have observed, these are very well designed and made - I don't believe I have seen any better reel cases other than some top of the line tanned leather reel cases. And they look like they will last a long time, as well as provide good protection for your fly reels. My one caveat (which others have also voiced) is that they are smaller than you would expect from the descriptions. I ordered a couple of each of the three sizes. Although the small supposedly has a 3-1/2" diameter, it would not hold a 3-1/8" Hardy Perfect reel or even a L.L. Bean's Double L Model 3/4 reel, that has a 2-5/8" diameter (and that is about the smallest working reel I own). Not only does the diameter appear to be overstated, but they are also quite shallow, and even though I could just barely get the Bean reel into the case, I could not come close to closing it (which would have been true even if I could have removed the handle from the reel). Based upon my measurement, the inside diameter of the small case is about 3-1/8", but because the case is so shallow, it will not accommodate a reel with a 3" diameter, particularly if you consider that the foot of the reel also needs to fit and the handle requires additional depth. To avoid having to return for an exchange, I would strongly recommend ordering a size larger than the descriptions would suggest (this applies to the other sizes, as well as the small).
April 23, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by Rd413 Perfect
Bought two of these as both my wife and I have 3 wt pocket water rods and reels. The case is a perfect fit for the 3 wt reels and is exactly what I wanted.
March 26, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by reubj Very nice.
Well constructed and very nice looking. The medium size fits the Pflueger Medalist 1494 perfectly.
March 21, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by ExEd Exactly fit my needs
I new when I ordered this good looking and very well made reel case that my extra spool might not fit but as it turns out it was a perfect fit. The spool is actually somewhat larger than the sizes given in the case description. I am very happy with this purchase as with most purchases from L.L. Bean.
March 19, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by dkfish4fun Very High Quality for the price
I am really impressed with the quality and great look of this reel case. The only thing I would do differently is order a larger size. I got the small for a 4 /5wt and it was a little too small. I am saving it for sometime when I might get a 2 or 3 wt.
February 10, 2014
Rated 5 out of 5 by WinFly A Sixth Star
In June, I ordered three of the reel cases and, as the other reviews state, measure carefully. I meant to order mediums, inadvertently ordered smalls, which didn't fit even the spool of my smallest reel. That said, when Joe helped me straighten out my order (long story, but it was complicated), I really appreciated the quality of the cases. Mediums fit my spare spools fine, as well as my smallest reel. The sixth star is for Joe--he ensured I remain a Bean customer.
November 16, 2013
Rated 5 out of 5 by roava24 Waxed Canvas Reel Cases
This is no doubt the best reel case I own! Quality construction throughout, durable and classic design, and weatherproof. I have three medium cases and one small. When ordering be sure to measure your reel for diameter and height. The small reel case is very small and does not fit any of my reels but it makes a great fly pouch.
November 10, 2013